‘American Housewife’s’ Katy Mixon Isn’t Melissa McCarthy — and That’s OK With Her (2024)

Logo text

If a mint julep could talk, it would probably sound a whole lot like Katy Mixon. From her habit of punctuating every sentence with a “Honey” or a “Darlin’” or a “Pumpkin” to an accent that would have been right at home at a Designing Women reunion, she is the personification of intoxicating Southern charm.

Which was precisely what Diedrich Bader feared when he auditioned to play Mixon’s husband on her new ABC series, American Housewife. “At first, I thought, ‘Is she going to call me ‘Pumpkin’ the whole time?’ ” he tells The Hollywood Reporter. “She’s so charming and so disarming with her Southern hospitality; it can make you feel very disoriented. I can’t wait to get to work to see her every day now and, to be honest, I’m disappointed if she doesn’t call me ‘Pumpkin!’ ”

In American Housewife, originally titled The Second Fattest Housewife in Westport,Mixon plays Katie Otto, a smart-ass mom with three kids who worries she’s about to become one of the top two largest housewives in town. With a character like that, it’s easy to think of Mixon as the second coming of Melissa McCarthy, whose sister she played for six seasons on CBS’Mike & Molly. And not just because neither comedienne is exactly a size zero. They also share a bustling energy and attitude that can instantly grab an audience.

“Melissa is one of the most special people I’ve ever met,” explains 35-year-old Mixon, who grew up in Pensacola, Fla. “Just being around her and learning from her experiences really helped me. I got to witness her stepping into this divine appointment of hers. But we’re so different from each other. She’s from the North. I’m from the South!”

Related Stories

Related StoryFaces of Fall TV: Exclusive Photos of New Series Stars From Kristen Bell to Kiefer Sutherland

Instead, Mixon seems to find more similarities with herAmerican Housewife character. Katie Otto is a woman who believes that, according to Mixon, “life is about meeting yourself wherever you are. She understands you don’t have to be perfect every time. Just accept your insecurities and walk into the fire. You don’t have to conform to expectations. Katie tries to be better but fails and fails again.”

Like her character, Mixon grew up in the suburbs. She was one of nine children — six girls, three boys — and credits her big family for giving her a relentlessly upbeat approach to life. “There were days when things were just dark, when I wasn’t feeling good about myself,” she recalls. “But my family got me to ask, ‘What’s the big picture here?’ And it’s positivity. That’s what life is about.”

Unlike TV Katie, though, Mixon has little interest in keeping a lookout for any women heavier than she is. She smoothly downplays any discussion of her own body type by saying she’s been “a size two and a size 14. I’ve literally not looked right for any part, but I just try to be me whenever I go in for a role. Everyone is different in what they want, but this is me and God bless it! If I’m big, I’m big. If I’m skinny, then I’m skinny.”

Still, she realizes that housewives of all shapes and sizes around the country will look to her as a role model in the same way that everyone from Lucille Ball to Roseanne Barr to Marge Simpson has become a role model over the years.

“It’d be a big honor if that were to happen,” gushes Mixon, who draws her inspiration from childhood heroes like Ball and Carol Burnett. “I’m just an actor. You know what I’m talking about? So to be thrust into that role would be amazing.”

Related Stories

Related StoryABC Drops "Fattest" From "Fattest Housewife" Pilot Title

So far so good on that front. In fact, she’s already a role model to her TV husband. “Katy has a great deal of inner strength,” Bader explains. “She’s a normal-size woman in an environment where women are constantly judged by each other. That’s a very difficult thing to get through, but she and her character are willing to do it. She brings this great intangible. Watching her reminds me of when I first worked with Drew Carey on his show. When we rehearsed, I didn’t get it. Once I saw him on camera, I totally got it. What Katy has can’t be nailed down, but right away you know you care about her.”

The veteran actor admits that at his first chemistry read for ABC, he “got nervous because just meeting her you knew this show was going to get picked up. And I wanted to be a part of it.” He’d considered Mixon “a megawatt star” from her time on the HBO series Eastbound and Down, along the lines of classic film stars like Jean Arthur and Rosalind Russell.

However, he was less sure about what he would find off-camera. Thankfully, he was pleasantly surprised. She’s “the real deal, a genuinely nice person, which is incredibly rare in Hollywood,” he says. “And trust me, I’ve seen her after she’d been working for 14 hours and started getting really sick. Katy is terrific but…I am kind of hoping they cut out the kissing scene after I saw her get sick.”

No matter how long her days are or how upset her stomach feels, though, Mixon is still going to tell you how happy she is. And throw in at least one term of endearment so you know she means it.

“Life is quite crazy now, but I’m handling it, honey!” says the actress who, not surprising, prefers to spend her weekends adhering to a particular Southern tradition: relaxing on the couch in sweatpants watching college football with a pet and a loved one. After all, she adds, “my daddy did play for LSU!”

Finding that football time probably won’t be easy for a while, though. She says, “What’s wild is I’m filming five days a week for 17 hours a day because I’m in practically every scene. And I’m still so grateful for this experience.”

American Housewife premieres Tuesday at 8:30 p.m. on ABC.

‘American Housewife’s’ Katy Mixon Isn’t Melissa McCarthy — and That’s OK With Her (2024)


Are Katy Mixon and Melissa McCarthy friends in real life? ›

They really love each other, they have that they really dig each other. And that's so fun to watch. You don't see that on TV a lot.” Mixon landed the role on the show soon after wrapping six seasons of “Mike & Molly,” playing Victoria opposite Melissa McCarthy.

Why did the cast of American Housewife change? ›

Answer: Julia Butters, who played Anna-Kat Otto through the comedy's first four seasons, departed the show before the fifth season, reportedly to pursue other opportunities. While that's a phrase that is often used when people leave a show, in this case it's true.

Why did they replace Katie friends in American Housewife? ›

Here's what happened to Katie's friends on 'American Housewife. ' Holly Robinson Peete and Jake Choi joined the cast of American Housewife in 2021, after Carly Hughes stepped down from Angela's role over concerns about racial discrimination. On the show, Holly plays Tami, Katie's old mentor and close friend.

Why did Julia Butters leave American Housewife? ›

Butters earned acclaim and landed a slew of nominations for her role in the movie, which opened a lot of doors for her. The young actress and her team wanted to pursue them and the studio behind American Housewife, ABC Signature, granted her request to leave the series.

Are Melissa McCarthy and Susan Sarandon friends in real life? ›

'This affair happened a very long time ago when Susan and Bowie were both young and carefree,' adds the source. 'Susan has fond memories of the love affair, but throughout the years have kept it private. ' 'Melissa and Susan have become very good friends and that is how melissa got to know about it.

Is there a different actress playing Anna-Kat on American Housewife? ›

American Housewife Recasts Anna-Kat; Giselle Eisenberg Replaces Julia Butters - IMDb.

Why did Angela and Doris leave American Housewife? ›

American Housewife's Carly Hughes has left the ABC show after four seasons as a series regular, citing a “toxic environment” for the reason behind her decision. Hughes appeared on the series as Angela, one of Katie's (Katy Mixon) real Westport mom friends alongside Ali Wong who stars as Doris.

Why did they change Katie? ›

Bianca had to depart the role after season two due to scheduling conflicts of another project she was due to take part in. Bianca can next be seen in Apple TV+'s Lady in the Lake.

Is Anna-Kat autistic on American Housewife? ›

Anna-Kat has obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), which causes her to act different than other kids her age. Anna-Kat washes her hands multiple times, is afraid of germs, pees in the yard, walks up the stairs in some sort of pattern, and more. As she's gotten older, her quirks have started to become less frequent.

Why was Taylor replaced on American Housewife? ›

recast by the actress Mac Donnelly. at the the second episode. The creators replaced Taylor. because she was not perfect for the role.

Why isn t the original Anna-Kat in American Housewife? ›

Having over the years watched American Housewife for Julia Butters and her character Anna-Kat I wasn't surprised to hear that she had left the show to pursue other opportunities as her PR stated so it was undertandabl;e that she would be re-cast and I also understand why Giselle Eisenberg was cast having seen her in ...

Did Mike and Molly get along in real life? ›

Billy Gardell and Reno Wilson are good friends in real life. They had been looking for a project they could do together when Gardell was approached about this show. They agreed it was an ideal situation, and Gardell asked for Wilson to be brought in. Mike & Molly's home is the same set from Roseanne (1988).

Are Jenny and Melissa McCarthy friends? ›

The two cousins, who spent their childhood years together with their expansive family, remain on good terms but are rarely seen in public together. Melissa didn't even attend Jenny's small wedding to Donnie Wahlberg last year. She told Howard Stern that she and her cousin are in “opposite worlds” these days.

Does Katy Mixon really sing in Mike and Molly? ›

Additionally, the actress has a beautiful singing voice. Katy Mixon singing in Mike & Molly wowed many of her fans.

Who is the cousin of Melissa McCarthy? ›

Jenny McCarthy

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Greg Kuvalis

Last Updated:

Views: 5932

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Greg Kuvalis

Birthday: 1996-12-20

Address: 53157 Trantow Inlet, Townemouth, FL 92564-0267

Phone: +68218650356656

Job: IT Representative

Hobby: Knitting, Amateur radio, Skiing, Running, Mountain biking, Slacklining, Electronics

Introduction: My name is Greg Kuvalis, I am a witty, spotless, beautiful, charming, delightful, thankful, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.